Monitor calibration is now universally seen as an important part of quality image making. In photography, it's rare to see anyone doing serious work without a monitor calibrator, and even graphic designers — often surprisingly reluctant to move on from the days of Pantone books and CMYK — have got the message that calibration is the way to go.
Put simply, to do reliable, accurate digital imaging work, you need to be able to see and assess on-screen colour accurately. Your screen, and your perception of it, will influence every single image you make, and calibrating it is the bare minimum you should be doing to keep it honest.
However, it's all too common to see people who own a calibrator and have given up using it after running into problems (most likely a failed unit), or who bought a calibrator years ago and dig it out once a year assuming it's still bringing them accuracy. It won't. Calibrators can and do fail, and they also simply wear out over time.
Why Calibrators Don't Last Forever
From a general scientific standpoint, calibration equipment usually requires annual re-certification to be considered accurate. But with consumer-level devices (roughly those in the $0–$600 range), the cost of re-certifying an individual unit is prohibitive, so it's generally not offered as a service. Instead, you're relying on the device's own construction to stay accurate over its working life.
For a long time, the major weak point in consumer colorimeters was the type of filter used over the sensor. In our experience at Image Science, calibrators using standard organic (dye-printed) filters reliably held their accuracy for around three years — this covered the entire Spyder range through to the X, and the i1 models before the current Display Pro generation. Dye-printed filters change over time like any colour-printed item, and a small change in the filter can cause a big change in the calibrator's colour measurement. This has largely been resolved industry-wide: DataColor's Spyder X/X2 range finally moved away from organic filters, about a decade after X-Rite (now Calibrite) solved the same problem in their Display Pro line.
What causes a calibrator to drift
- Filter ageing. Older, open-filter-design calibrators are quite vulnerable to changes in temperature and humidity. Newer models use double-printed filters designed to last longer.
- Changing monitor technology. Because almost all monitor calibrators are colorimeters, they rely on internal colour filters tuned to read the monitors of their era — CRT, then standard-gamut fluorescent-lit LCD, and now LED and wide-gamut displays. As monitor technology moves on, an older calibrator becomes a progressively less reliable measure of a current monitor's colour.
- Operating system and driver support. Older calibrators can lose OS support outright — for example, i1Display 2 support was dropped for macOS Mountain Lion and above, and Spyder 4 and below were abandoned with Catalina.
Cost of Ownership
Assuming a minimum three-year lifespan for an organic-filter calibrator, the cost of ownership works out to roughly $50–$100 a year — a very small price for accuracy and reliability. If you're a professional, one ruined job will cover that cost many times over. If you're a hobbyist, it's more about not wasting time and materials chasing results you were never going to get with a drifting calibrator.
Manufacturer warranties on these devices are 12 months, and none of the major makers have moved on this despite plenty of pushback from us over the years. In practice, most units do last three or more years, so this is usually more of a theoretical concern than a practical one.
Dichroic Filters Last Much Longer
Around our site, you'll see we favour the Calibrite Display Plus HL and Calibrite Display Pro HL calibrators over the other available options, including the Spyder range — see our i1Display Pro vs Spyder comparison for the full picture. One of the key reasons is that these use dichroic (non-organic) filters rather than dye-printed ones.
As Wikipedia puts it: "Dichroic filters have a much longer life than conventional filters; the colour is intrinsic in the construction of the hard microscopic layers and cannot 'bleach out' over the lifetime of the filter" — unlike gel filters. We usually explain it as dichroic filters behaving more like glass prisms: the light-filtering behaviour doesn't meaningfully change over time, the way printed organic filters do. You can take a measurement with an i1Display Pro from over a decade ago and compare it to one taken today, and they'll behave near identically. Do the same with an old Spyder across a three-year period and you'll see a significant measurable difference.
This is one of the main reasons we recommend the Calibrite Display Pro / Plus HL range as our primary calibrators — they hold their accuracy for a much longer effective lifespan (at least 10 years and counting) than other commonly available colorimeters.
Troubleshooting an Older Calibrator
If you have an older monitor calibrator, or one that doesn't seem to work with your current operating system or monitor, there's often a solution. A lot of people run into trouble calibrating a new wide-gamut monitor with an old calibrator, or finding drivers after moving to a new OS version.
There's an excellent open-source colour calibration system called ArgyllCMS. A second project, DisplayCAL, adds a proper user interface on top of it for monitor calibration, and is compatible with a long list of sensors across Linux, macOS and Windows. Read more on our own DisplayCAL article before you toss an older calibrator in the bin.
An Alternative: Spectrophotometers
If replacing your calibrator every three years feels like too much, from a cost or environmental perspective, a spectrophotometer is worth considering instead. Though more expensive up front, spectrophotometers — particularly LED-light-source models, which is effectively all current ones — tend to have very long working lives, since LEDs are inherently stable. We've found our own spectrophotometers are often still reliable at 10 years or more, which can bring the cost of ownership to $50/year or less, with printer profiling and spot-colour measurement thrown in as a bonus.
The caveat is that spectrophotometers aren't quite as strong at monitor calibration as the best colorimeters — they're a little weaker at measuring shadow detail, which matters both because monitors tend to struggle there and because shadow detail is critical in fine art print work. So for the best monitor calibration specifically, we still recommend a well-kept, relatively current colorimeter such as the Calibrite Display Pro or Plus HL.
Keep Your Colour Accurate, Screen to Print
- Browse our current range in the Monitor Calibrators collection.
- Shop the Calibrite Display Pro HL or Calibrite Display Plus HL.
- Once your monitor is calibrated, match your printer with our Custom Printer Profiling service.