Calibration Versus Profiling: The Short Version
Calibration sets a device into its best native state using its own hardware controls.
Profiling is the process of measuring, and then correcting for, any remaining inaccuracies in a device's colour output by modifying the signal going into it.
Colour management works best when both processes are used together: first a calibration is completed, then a profile is built of the device in its now-calibrated state.
More basic colour management systems often only offer one of the two:
- Calibration only — for example, a printer offering a 'linearisation' function that performs a basic calibration.
- Profiling only — for example, a cheaper monitor colour management system that profiles the monitor in whatever state it happens to be in when you start, without guiding you through calibration first.
What Calibration Does
Calibration uses hardware adjustments on a device to set it into a known, repeatable state — ideally close to some absolute benchmark for that device's behaviour. An example is adjusting your monitor's brightness control to a specific point, say 120 candelas.
CRT monitors
Most CRT monitors have extensive hardware calibration controls for brightness, contrast and colour. On good-quality models, individual control over the red, green and blue gains is available; cheaper models usually only offer colour presets to choose from.
Cheaper to mid-level LCD monitors
Most cheaper to mid-level LCD monitors have only one true hardware control: brightness. Your monitor may expose other controls, but unless they're specifically advertised as true hardware adjustments, it's generally best to ignore them — they're often actually being applied in your video card rather than in the monitor itself. For the best quality from a screen like this, adjust only the brightness and leave contrast, colour and the rest at their factory defaults.
High-end LCD monitors (such as Eizo)
High-end LCD monitors, such as those made by Eizo, offer true hardware adjustments for brightness and for red, green and blue gains, much like a good-quality CRT. These monitors have an internal video processor — usually working in 10, 14 or 16-bit precision, well beyond your computer's 8-bit video card LUT — where the adjustments are made at much higher quality. On monitors like these, you should adjust both brightness and the colour controls during the calibration stage.
Note: no LCD monitor has a true contrast control — they only have fixed contrast ratios. You should always run an LCD monitor over a digital connection rather than an analogue one for better results across the board, most noticeably in sharpness and colour accuracy.
What Profiling Does
Profiling is the process of measuring a device's colour output, then correcting the signal sent to that device to achieve more accurate colour.
It's easiest to understand with an example. Say we want a particular shade of red on a device — call it Red 50. We send the Red 50 signal to the device and see what colour it actually produces. Say it produces Red 55 — now we know the device is outputting a little too much red. Next we try sending Red 45, and this time the device produces Red 50. From then on, whenever we want the device to display Red 50, we send it Red 45 instead.
Repeat this for a number of colours — the more colours profiled, the more accurate the result — and you end up with a table of input signals and the colours they actually produce:
- Red 45 → produces → Red 50
- Red 50 → produces → Red 55
- Blue 23 → produces → Blue 17
- ...and so on
So if we want a particular colour — say, Blue 17 — we refer back to the table to see what signal to send the device, in this case Blue 23. That's essentially what a profile is: an accurate description of a device, usually in table form, mapping input signals to the real colours they produce.
Why Order Matters
Profiling works best when the device itself is already behaving well — the better a device's inherent behaviour, the easier it is for a profile to produce accurate colour across its full gamut. This is why devices should be calibrated before they're profiled: skip calibration and the results won't be as accurate.
This is also the key flaw in cheaper colour management systems: they simply profile the device in whatever state it happens to be in. The resulting profiles often have to make very large corrections, which leads to poorer-quality results overall compared with a device that was properly calibrated first.
Put This Into Practice
- Learn how we use profiles for printers on our ICC Profiles page.
- Browse monitor calibrators in our Monitor Calibrators collection.
- Get your printer accurately profiled with our Custom Printer Profiling service.