Your First A4 Print is On Us. Learn More

Please make an appointment before visiting the studio - other than your order collections.     PH: 03 9329 4522

Welcome to the new Image Science website!

ProPhoto or ConPhoto?

Abstract rainbow of coloured light streaks, illustrating the wide colour gamut discussed in this article on ProPhoto RGB

Why ProPhoto Still Divides Opinion

The merits and problems of ProPhoto RGB are a topic that comes up over and over again in digital imaging discussions. In many ways the point is now moot — tools like Lightroom use ProPhoto in the background whether you like it or not. But it's still worth understanding the implications of ProPhoto, and it's still definitely relevant for any files you export from raw to a finished image.

What follows is a long article — originally written in 2005 — that discusses the issues in depth.

The ProPhoto colour space plotted on a LAB colour model, showing its very wide gamut
Figure 1: The ProPhoto Colour Space plotted on LAB

Background and Knowledge Required

Because this is a question we're asked so often, here are a few notes on the negatives of using ProPhoto, because a lot of people gloss over them. There are some real potential downsides to using ProPhoto over the (still) more popular and established Adobe RGB. It's not that ProPhoto is never appropriate — it's that, used incorrectly, it can lead to real, tangible problems in your editing and printing that can be very frustrating.

Like all things in digital imaging, your decision to use (or not use) ProPhoto should be an explicit, informed decision based on real knowledge and testing, not just word of mouth and internet mythology.

You won't really follow this discussion if you don't know a few basics about colour spaces. If any of the facts in the section below are a surprise to you, or you simply don't know what they mean, it's worth bolstering your knowledge of basic colour management first — especially before considering the use of ProPhoto. We have comprehensive notes on colour management in our online Fundamentals of Digital book. It's probably the quickest and most effective way to get up to speed on digital colour.

If you want to print your images to the highest level possible, you need to understand digital colour management. Without it, you're relying on guesswork and the fairly poor colour management practices of most labs, and little more than luck when it comes to print quality.

Colour Space Basics: Quick Revision

  • In the RGB colour model, digital colour is represented by each pixel having a value for Red, Green and Blue, where 0 is black and 255 is the colour primary (or 0 and 65535 in colour spaces with 16-bit depth).
  • All colour spaces of the same bit depth (typically 8 or 16 bit) have the same total number of tones. A bigger colour space does not mean there are more colours in total. 8 bits = 256 tones per channel (i.e. possible red values of 0 to 255); 16 bits = 65,536 tones per channel.
  • It is the distance between tones that varies between colour spaces.
  • The gamut of a colour space is all the tones representable within it — defined by the 'borders' of the colour space (the Red, Green and Blue primaries) and the distance between tones (decided by bit depth).
  • sRGB is a relatively narrow-gamut colour space (see Figure 2).
  • Adobe RGB is a medium to large gamut colour space (see Figure 3).
  • ProPhoto is a very large gamut colour space.
  • Even the best monitors struggle to display 98% of Adobe RGB. Unless your screen cost in the region of AU$7,500 or more, the odds are your monitor's gamut is only slightly larger than sRGB, and about one third of the size of ProPhoto.
  • Colour spaces are either device dependent (representing the physical properties of an input or output device) or device independent (a theoretical colour space).
  • Put simply, RGB primaries are either real (colours visible to the human eye) or imaginary (theoretical colours not visible to the human eye). ProPhoto's blue and green primaries are imaginary.
  • Banding results when the distance between tones in areas of smooth tonality is too great for the human eye to perceive the gradation as smooth.
  • Although printer drivers are almost all 8-bit, editing in 16-bit will give you better results. The final conversion to 8-bit should happen only immediately before printing.
Diagram comparing the ProPhoto colour space against sRGB, showing how much larger ProPhoto is
Figure 2: ProPhoto is truly massive compared to sRGB
Diagram comparing the ProPhoto colour space against Adobe RGB, showing ProPhoto's much larger gamut
Figure 3: ProPhoto is much bigger still than even Adobe RGB

Using ProPhoto to Edit 8-Bit Image Files

Using ProPhoto with 8-bit files is a recipe for trouble. It's remarkably easy to introduce banding to a file in 8-bit ProPhoto — and little makes a digital image look worse, faster.

ProPhoto is so large that having only 255 possible shades of each of Red, Green and Blue becomes a real problem. The distance between tones is so vast that you're almost guaranteed banding with only slight manipulations, especially if you try to recover detail in a slightly underexposed area of an image — the shadows, in particular.

Using ProPhoto for RAW Image Files

We might use ProPhoto simply because it is enormous. It is the only commonly used device-independent colour space that (almost) completely contains the gamuts of all the device-dependent colour spaces you're likely to encounter.

This is a strong argument in favour of ProPhoto, and stronger still if your capture device is a high-quality scanner or a modern digital camera, as older devices rarely had sensors capable of measuring colours outside of Adobe RGB (for many, sRGB was approximately the limit). Modern cameras and scanners do have sensors that can measure colours outside of Adobe RGB, though usually not by much.

The basic argument for using ProPhoto as the destination colour space in your RAW converter or scanning software is that there's then no chance of losing anything in the future. ProPhoto can contain almost every tone your camera, film or scanner can capture (and usually a good deal more), so you are never clipping channels — beyond the colour information already lost by the sensor itself.

An obvious counter-argument is that it makes more sense to keep the RAW (or DNG) file and re-process it as needed, using the best available technology and colour space at the time. As soon as you convert from RAW to ProPhoto (or from your scanner's colour space to ProPhoto), you've already made decisions and lost some of the information available to you in the original file.

So ProPhoto isn't really the best storage space for archiving digital images either — although a ProPhoto TIFF is likely to remain more compatible in future than your camera's RAW format. Some RAW formats from early digital cameras already won't open in current RAW converter software; Adobe's DNG format may solve that problem.

Converting from RAW into ProPhoto makes some sense, as you're unlikely to run into any significant clipping. That said, it's not actually common for your images to contain tones outside of Adobe RGB — it tends to be only images with extremely saturated colour (particularly yellows) that raise this problem, easily seen using the histogram in Adobe Camera Raw. If your original capture doesn't contain tones outside the gamut of Adobe RGB, there's no benefit (and quite a few downsides) to using ProPhoto as your working space, unless you plan to artificially push the saturation of your image a long way.

If your image does contain tones outside of Adobe RGB's gamut, using ProPhoto makes more sense — though it's still not necessarily the best option, which brings us to the core of the issue.

Output-Centric versus "Wundershot" Thinking

Professional photographers know how hard it is to make a truly worthy image. Amateurs always believe they might get lucky and capture one someday. Professionals are generally in the business of image creation; amateurs, the business of image capture. Working photographers are generally more interested in getting good results in a limited time span, on a sensible budget, and within the limitations of the equipment they're currently working with. Hobby photographers have the luxury of testing things at length.

Working photographers are interested in techniques that make their work look good now (and get them more work); hobbyists take the long view — they can get their images scanned and printed beautifully later, and try the same image in many forms over many years. Professionals tend to be output-centric (what will work now, for good results) and hobbyists "Wundershot"-centric (how do I make the most of that once-in-a-lifetime shot, and print it beautifully for years to come?). Both are valid in their own right — but go too far down the Wundershot path and you may find you're missing out on great prints now, in the hope of something that may never come.

ProPhoto colour space plotted against an ICC output profile for an Epson inkjet printer
Figure 4: ProPhoto and an output profile for the Epson 2100

What does this have to do with ProPhoto? It comes down to the gamuts of current output devices — which aren't that big. In volume terms, they're all pretty much smaller than Adobe RGB. This includes inkjets, photographic printers and every other output method you're likely to use. Not one of them has a gamut larger than Adobe RGB overall. However, many do have gamuts that don't completely overlap Adobe RGB — in some cases, as much as 5 to 10% of their gamut may fall outside it. Typically it's saturated yellows that are the culprit (occasionally very saturated cyans and magentas too, though that's less common).

ProPhoto colour space plotted against a photographic printer's gamut on Kodak Endura paper
Figure 5: ProPhoto and the Durst Lamda using Kodak Endura paper

So unless you're photographing unusually intense colour — very saturated yellows in particular — almost all of the tones you can print, or are likely to print in the short to mid-term, are nicely contained within Adobe RGB. Working in Adobe RGB rather than ProPhoto makes more sense in most cases. For those images that do contain printable, out-of-Adobe-RGB-gamut colours, ProPhoto may be the better choice — but you'd be choosing it for a specific, sensible reason.

Adobe RGB colour space plotted against a printer's gamut, highlighting saturated yellows that fall outside Adobe RGB
Figure 6: Adobe RGB and the Durst Lamda — note the saturated yellows outside of the Adobe RGB gamut

A huge proportion of the best, award-winning, technically stunning photographs of recent years have been printed from Adobe RGB files (using good output profiles, of course). Not enough saturated tones in there for you? Unlikely. Would ProPhoto have been a better colour space to use? Not very often. Will using ProPhoto make your imagery better? Not very often. Will it make it worse? Sometimes — quite possibly.

Which brings us to why smaller is often better when it comes to colour spaces (provided you're not clipping anything important).

Using the Correct Colour Space for Your Image

The ideal colour space for any particular image is the one that doesn't clip any tones — large enough to contain the most saturated tones in the scene, but no larger. To paraphrase the points above: the bigger a colour space, the bigger the gaps between tones, and the greater the likelihood of banding (remember, all colour spaces of the same bit depth, regardless of size, have the same total number of tones).

In 8-bit, this means you'll very often get banding with ProPhoto. You might assume that in 16-bit there are so many tones available that banding becomes impossible. It's true it's much less of a problem, but that's not the case in shadows. Editing software also tends to accumulate rounding errors fairly quickly — the net effect being tones falling into the same "buckets". Several adjustment layers used to take your image from good to great can very quickly introduce banding in ProPhoto.

Another reason to be wary of ProPhoto is that you simply can't see most of it. Your monitor's gamut is typically about a third of the size of ProPhoto (see Figure 7). Two-thirds of the tones storable in ProPhoto can never be seen by you, on screen or in print.

If you make a fairly common adjustment — say, +10% saturation — to an image that's already reasonably saturated, there's a good chance you won't be able to see with any accuracy what's happening to the numbers in your file (out-of-gamut colours for your monitor are always mapped back in using Relative Colorimetric rendering). This is a real problem in practice: soft-proofing files with large proportions of numbers well outside your monitor's or printer's gamut can be genuinely difficult.

ProPhoto colour space compared to a high-end monitor's colour gamut, showing how much of ProPhoto sits outside what a monitor can display
Figure 7: ProPhoto swallowing a top-class monitor's colour space, seen from below

The In-Gamut Colours from Way Out

Another problem with ProPhoto is that, especially with less subtle edits, a large proportion of tones in a file often end up well out of gamut for the output device. At output, these tones have to be mapped back into gamut. There are four rendering intents available to do this in Photoshop — only Perceptual and Relative Colorimetric are really useful in practice.

In both cases, bringing well-out-of-gamut tones back into gamut requires some fairly aggressive maths — the further out of gamut the colours, the more aggressive it gets. In practice, this can make achieving a fine, smooth print that much harder. Adobe RGB was designed to sit specifically close to the gamuts of most output devices, so this is less of a problem.

Subtle Like a Hammer

Editing tools offer only one level of finesse, regardless of the colour space you're using. ProPhoto is so wide that sometimes even the minimum 1% change is too much — 100% stretched over such a vast space makes 1% a significant shift. Be wary of making large changes in ProPhoto, especially since you'll quickly run into the edges of your monitor's gamut and won't be able to actually see those changes.

Going from an okay print to a great print is often the result of very subtle, targeted manipulations of the source file, made with real intent. That subtlety can be harder to achieve in ProPhoto than in other colour spaces.

Labs Without a Clue

If you don't do your own printing, and have a lab print your work, be aware that many labs (at least historically, in Australia) have been fairly weak on colour management. Many production systems are still based around sRGB or Adobe RGB, and plenty of labs don't really know what ProPhoto is. Supply a file with colours significantly outside the Adobe RGB gamut and you're at real risk of a disappointing print — one you'll still be charged for.

The ACMP (the professional body for commercial photographers in Australia) has standards for digital files, namely that files are supplied in Adobe RGB.

A Quick Summary

  • ProPhoto is huge — so huge you can't visualise most of it on your screen, and can't print most of it.
  • ProPhoto is really too big for 8-bit files in any situation where you're going to edit the image — it's just too easy to introduce banding, especially in shadows.
  • Printing images where many tones sit outside your output device's gamut is problematic, and soft-proofing becomes harder and less accurate.
  • Banding is always a real possibility with ProPhoto, even in 16-bit files — watch those shadows in particular.
  • While some devices can capture tones outside of Adobe RGB, most real images don't contain them. Saturated yellows are one area to watch, and the one area where printers generally exceed Adobe RGB's gamut — though tones that saturated aren't especially common.
  • It's easy to inadvertently make bigger changes than you intended, in ProPhoto.
  • ProPhoto is the right choice in some cases — but understand why you're using it, and the consequences of that decision, and you'll get better results.
  • Many labs (at least in Australia) still treat ProPhoto files as an unknown quantity. If you need to use ProPhoto for editing, supply your final file to your lab as Adobe RGB.

Test It for Yourself

Don't just take this as gospel — test it yourself and see whether it holds up. Use a gamut-plotting tool alongside our custom printer profiling service to plot the gamut of your printer against Adobe RGB and ProPhoto. Try some edits on an 8-bit ProPhoto file and look for banding in the deep shadows. Try to find an image from your camera with significant colour outside the Adobe RGB gamut. Process the same file (a typical portrait, and a saturated sunset) in both ProPhoto and Adobe RGB and see which print you prefer. Calibrate and profile your monitor and compare its gamut to ProPhoto's.

Prove to yourself that you've made the right decision, and that you understand why you made it.

Want to Go Deeper on Colour Management?

If this raised more questions than it answered, our colour management theory chapter works through colour spaces, gamut and rendering intents in more detail, and our full Fundamentals of Digital ebook covers colour management from first principles through to practical workflow. If you'd rather have a set of eyes on your printer's actual gamut, our custom printer profiling service gives you an ICC profile built for your specific printer and paper.

Related Reading