Your First A4 Print is On Us. Learn More

Please make an appointment before visiting the studio - other than your order collections.     PH: 03 9329 4522

Welcome to the new Image Science website!

Calibrating Dual or Multiple Monitors

Three monitors set up side by side on a desk for dual/multi-monitor colour work

Matching multiple monitors together so they appear identical to the marvellously sensitive human eye is very, very difficult.

Naively, we assume that if we calibrate a monitor, the colour that comes out of it afterwards will be correct — and that's sort of true, within the limitations of the monitor's abilities. So it feels like it should follow that if you calibrate two monitors, the visual results should be a close match between those screens.

Unfortunately, this is rarely the case. Even two monitors of exactly the same brand and model, bought on the same day, will usually not appear to match perfectly once calibrated. For many people, this is a huge and unpleasant surprise.

Why Multiple Monitor Calibration Fails

There are many reasons multiple monitor calibration doesn't achieve a visual match between screens. Like most things, solving this is far more complex than it first looks. Here are some of the reasons it doesn't work the way we naturally expect:

  • The human eye is so sensitive that when you see large blocks of a single tone (e.g. your desktop background, or a white screen), it will pick up even slight differences in tone.
  • In particular, the way white balance and chromatic adaptation work in the human eye means we're extraordinarily sensitive to differences in white tones (i.e. the monitor's white balance). Even an untrained eye will see the most minute difference in white.
  • Manufacturing tolerances exist — e.g. in LED backlighting — so unit-to-unit variance is higher than you might think, even with very high quality screens.
  • Making things truly match would require prohibitively expensive machines: calibrators that can detect these marginal differences, and screens with fractional levels of adjustment fine enough to fix them.
  • It would also take a prohibitive amount of time — the system would have to measure and correct thousands, if not millions, of tones to achieve a genuinely perfect visual match.
  • In rare cases, the video system doesn't support calibration at all.

How Do We Best Solve This?

The fact is, this isn't a problem you can fully solve — the human eye is simply too good at picking out the slightest differences. So given that, what's best practice?

Some monitor calibration software lets you load the profile made for one monitor into another, in theory so the secondary screen adapts itself to the primary. In practice, we've never seen this work particularly well.

The best approach is to designate one screen — your best screen — as your primary reference monitor for colour work, then calibrate any other screens 'to' that reference screen for the closest visual match. We typically recommend doing this at a slightly lower brightness on the secondary screen, so your eyes' white balance stays biased towards the primary.

In practice, this means adjusting the calibration target of the secondary screen however you can to improve the visual match. For example, on our primary workstation here we run an Eizo ColorEdge monitor alongside a second, lower-tier screen. We designate the Eizo as the primary reference monitor and calibrate it to our usual fine art printing target (90 cd/m2, 5800K white, 0.4 black, gamma 2.2, full native gamut).

Initially, we calibrate the secondary screen to the same settings, except we lower the brightness slightly to help our eyes stay white-balanced to the primary screen. After this first calibration, we visually assess the match against the Eizo — the best way to do this is with a continuous-tone test image (like the PDI printer test image), rather than your desktop or large blocks of flat colour, since the goal is to improve the match in overall colour reproduction — not just specific tones (unless a particular family of tones matters most to you, in which case use an image with those tones).

With the test image displayed, check for overall issues:

  • Is the secondary screen warmer or cooler than the reference screen? If so, recalibrate it to a different white point to compensate (the exact number is irrelevant — you're chasing a better visual match).
  • Is the secondary screen higher or lower in contrast? If so, experiment with different black points or gammas.
  • ...and so on.

In every case, you're adjusting the calibration target arbitrarily, purely to improve the visual match. Once you've done the best you can, that's genuinely as far as it goes — this is a problem that isn't fully solvable. (This is also a good argument for buying one really big, great monitor rather than two smaller ones.)

That said, once you've done this, you can normally reach a thoroughly workable result — just remember to do all your critical colour work on the primary screen. This is what we do here, and it works well.

The Technical Stuff

Getting dual or multiple monitor calibration working on your system is hardware-specific and differs with every setup. Generally it comes down to your LUTs (Look Up Tables) and whether you can address them separately.

Note that this section is specifically about software calibration systems (like you'd use with a Calibrite Display Plus HL or similar colorimeter, on normal monitors and laptops). If you have a monitor with direct hardware calibration support, the calibration is stored in the monitor itself, so just use the manufacturer's own software and all should be fine.

Not every question will be answered for every system here, so we do ask that you do your own research and testing. You might also want to read How Monitor Profiles Work, which covers some of the underlying concepts in more detail.

Multi-Monitor Calibration on a Mac

In general, on a Mac, multi-monitor calibration just works. Mac video cards must support separate LUTs for each video output to be compatible with macOS. Just drag your profiling app to each screen in turn, calibrate, and you should be done.

Multi-Monitor Calibration on a PC

On a PC, the key thing is how many LUTs your video card has, and whether you can address each one individually. This information can be hard to find — it's worth contacting your video card's maker directly, as computer retailers usually won't know the answer.

With a reasonably current video card and Windows 10 or 11, dual monitor calibration usually works out of the box — it's now unusual to find hardware without dual LUTs. If you're on older hardware, the simplest fix is to attach each monitor to a separate video card, since each card has its own LUT and can be associated with its own profile.

With a dual-headed video card, the card must offer separately addressable LUTs for each output, and this varies by card. Some claim not to support this but actually do (via separate tools); others claim to but aren't recognised as such by the operating system. Some driver updates for popular cards have disabled the second LUT, requiring older drivers to restore it, which can bring other side effects.

Should You Bother?

If you're having trouble getting dual or multiple monitor calibration working, it's worth asking whether the effort is really worthwhile. It's often perfectly fine to use a second screen purely for browsing and palettes, where colour management isn't really needed.

You can still manually adjust your second monitor to roughly match your primary screen — we do recommend keeping its brightness noticeably lower than your primary, so your eyes stay white-balanced to the primary display.

Products for Better Multi-Monitor Colour Matching

The single biggest lever here is monitor quality — a matched pair of high-end panels will always get you closer than mixing tiers. Browse our Eizo ColorEdge monitors and full monitor range, and if you're calibrating with a colorimeter rather than direct hardware calibration, see our monitor calibrators.

Related Reading